Good on paper
- Company named: MakeLoveNotPorn, LLC, New York
- 2257 statement: Custodian 2257Sentry, LLC, Somerville, NJ
- Pay rules in writing: 50% of each rental to the maker
- Content removal route: Content removal page in footer
- No age-marketing tags: No category list; no age terms in text
Watch out for
- Prices public: No rental or subscription prices in public text
- Third-party age check: 18+ account; no third-party check described
MakeLoveNotPorn is a platform for “real world sex videos” made by non-professional couples and individuals, founded by Cindy Gallop. You rent films one at a time or subscribe, and the homepage says 50% of each rental goes to the people in the video. It is the only site in this category that publishes a creator share as a number. It does not publish its rental prices in the public page text. This is a test drive based on the official pages, read on Nov 2, 2026. I did not pay or sign up. For the rest of the category, see the ethical porn sites hub.
On the word “ethical”: MakeLoveNotPorn’s homepage says “We’re the safest place on the internet”. That is the operator’s claim. I found no independent audit of creator pay or of its moderation for MakeLoveNotPorn or any other site in this category.
What it is
MakeLoveNotPorn is different from every studio on this list. Nobody is hired to perform. People film themselves, submit the video, the platform reviews it, and if it is published the makers earn from rentals. The homepage invites you to “watch real world sex videos in all their loving, hot, and messy humanness”.
The homepage says the project was born in 2009 out of the founder’s own experience, and it sells her TED book for $4.99. There is no category or tag list on the public homepage, only video titles. I read the homepage text for age-marketing or family-roleplay themes and found none.
How you pay
The terms of service describe two ways to watch:
| Option | How it works, per the terms |
|---|---|
| Pay-per-rental | Each film plays for 21 consecutive days, unlimited viewing, from approval of the order |
| Subscription | Monthly fee, includes a set number of films, renews automatically |
The homepage says “Subscribe or buy credits to rent”. The price of a rental is shown on each film’s page and at checkout, according to the terms, but it is not in the public text I could read. Subscription prices are not public either.
Trials. The terms say a trial converts into a paid subscription unless you cancel it on your subscription page before it ends. If you take a trial, set a reminder.
Cards. The terms say you need a Visa or Mastercard.
Refunds. The terms are blunt: subscriptions cannot be ended early and “we will not refund any fees that you have already paid”. Cancellation takes effect the day after the current period ends. If a rented film will not play, the company may replace it or refund it, at its discretion.
These terms were last updated on Feb 6, 2019, per the page.
The creator share
The homepage says: “Each time a video is rented, 50% goes directly back to the MakeLoveNotPornstar.” That is the only published share or pay figure I found among the six sites in this category.
What I could not read is the Video Submissions Agreement, which the terms say holds the payment terms for creators. So I do not know how payouts are calculated, when they are paid or whether there are fees.
Consent and moderation
The terms say the platform “requires consent from every participant” in a submitted video. They also say the company reserves the right, “but shall have no obligation”, to pre-screen content. The operator presents the site as moderated, but the terms themselves do not promise that every video is reviewed.
That matters. With user-submitted video, the question is how consent of everyone on screen is checked, and the public pages do not describe the process. I’d want to see that before calling the moderation strong.
Who runs it
The terms name MakeLoveNotPorn, LLC, 445 Fifth Avenue, PHA, New York, NY 10016, under New York law. Disputes go to binding arbitration with JAMS, with a class action waiver and a jury trial waiver. The 2257 compliance statement names 2257Sentry, LLC in Somerville, New Jersey, as records custodian. The footer also links to a content removal page.
Age checks
The terms say you must be at least 18 and of the age of majority where you live. I did not find a third-party viewer age check described on the pages I read.
Affiliate disclosure
I found no affiliate program for MakeLoveNotPorn, and we have no affiliate link for it. We list it because it fits the category, not because it pays us.
My take
On paper, MakeLoveNotPorn has the clearest money promise to the people on screen of any site here: half of every rental. It is also the only one built entirely on real people filming themselves, which is a different kind of product from a studio.
What to watch:
- No public prices for rentals or subscriptions.
- No refunds on fees already paid, and trials convert to paid.
- The creator agreement and the consent check process are not public.
- The terms date from 2019.
It might suit you if you want unscripted, non-professional video and like the idea of paying the makers directly, per rental. If you want a studio with printed prices, see AORTA films or JoyBear. If you want real couples within a studio catalog, XConfessions and Bright Desire both have real-couple sections.
FAQ
How much does MakeLoveNotPorn cost?
The public pages do not show prices. Per the terms, each rented film plays for 21 days, and there is also a monthly subscription that includes a set number of films. I'll add prices after a paid test.
How much do MakeLoveNotPorn creators get?
The homepage says 50% of each rental goes to the people in the video. The detailed payout terms are in a separate Video Submissions Agreement I could not read.
Can I get a refund from MakeLoveNotPorn?
The terms say fees already paid are not refunded and subscriptions cannot be ended early. For a rented film that will not play, the company may replace or refund it at its discretion.
Who owns MakeLoveNotPorn?
MakeLoveNotPorn, LLC, based at 445 Fifth Avenue in New York, per the terms of service. The founder is Cindy Gallop.
Is MakeLoveNotPorn ethical?
The operator calls itself "the safest place on the internet" and requires consent from every participant in its terms. I found no independent audit of creator pay or moderation, so this is the operator's claim.
Run MakeLoveNotPorn?
Correct a price, request a paid crash test or invite us to your affiliate program. Money never changes a score.
Contact the reviewerSpotted a price change on MakeLoveNotPorn? Tell us and we recheck it.
Paper check: 6.5/10
Ten yes/no checks against the official pages, checked Nov 2, 2026. Half a point when the answer is unclear. A crash test is scored separately. How the paper score works.
- Company namedMakeLoveNotPorn, LLC, New York
- 2257 statementCustodian 2257Sentry, LLC, Somerville, NJ
- Prices publicNo rental or subscription prices in public text
- ½Renewal terms clearTerms explain auto-renewal; no prices
- ½Written consent policyTerms require consent of every participant
- Pay rules in writing50% of each rental to the maker
- Third-party age check18+ account; no third-party check described
- Content removal routeContent removal page in footer
- ½Cancellation explainedCancel via subscription page; no refunds
- No age-marketing tagsNo category list; no age terms in text
Sites like MakeLoveNotPorn
Other Ethical porn we checked, ranked by our score.

I Feel Myself
Big archive of solo female videos in 4K, many self-filmed, from Feck

AORTA films
Queer studio and member library with a published consent page

Bright Desire
Ms Naughty's feminist films, with a written pay and consent policy

Beautiful Agony
Face-only orgasm videos sent in by contributors, from Dutch company Feck

JoyBear
British studio of plotted erotic films and real-couple scenes

OMGYes
Sex education on women's pleasure: real-women videos, one payment, no subscription







